In December of 2019, Robert Marbut was appointed to be the new homeless czar for the country.
If you do a Google search about this, you’ll find numerous articles about this appointment and about the numerous criticisms against Mr. Marbut for his approach to homelessness.
Here’s one sample:
“Marbut does not adhere to the “housing first” philosophy embraced by most U.S. cities, which aim to place people experiencing homelessness into stable, supportive housing before working to address any medical, financial, or substance abuse issues. This method is not only proven to help people stay housed, as it’s easier to tackle other issues once someone has a safe, stable place to sleep, but it also saves cities money by avoiding costly public expenditures for emergency care.
Instead, Marbut has recommended that cities stop giving out food, criminalize sidewalk sleeping, and force homeless residents who want services to move into city-operated facilities in large temporary structures that advocates have equated to jails.”
When you search for more articles on Mr. Marbut you find a multitude of homeless advocates being critical of Mr. Marbut and his approach to homelessness, with one critic saying that Mr. Marbut’s approach is a “real life horror.”
Mr. Marbut has one approach to homelessness. It’s not the approach I would take, nor has it been the approach that our congregation is taking in tackling homelessness. Frankly, it’s demeaning and dehumanizing. And it doesn’t work. Part of Mr. Marbut’s system is about making people earn everything to the point that at the shelter he ran in New Orleans:
“…access to the 1,000 beds must be earned. People entering the shelter must sleep on mats in an outdoor courtyard and can only move inside after participating in services like job training, education, and substance abuse counseling. Breaking rules like missing curfew can mean getting demoted back to the courtyard.”
Thankfully there are many different ways to dealing with homelessness. Housing First is a system that has worked well in many cases. In the housing first model, people are given housing and in doing so, it opens people to less anxiety. It allows them to spend their time and attention trying to resolve the numerous other issues they face on a daily basis. It keeps people healthier and out the emergency departments. In the long run, it is much cheaper to house people, rather than to keep them out of housing.
While I don’t have the ability to house people, I do have another approach – a ministry of presence. Our congregation doesn’t have the resources to house people. But we show up where people who are experiencing homelessness are. We get to know them, listen to their story. We do laundry with them. We eat with them. We worship with them. We make sure they get showers. We offer what supplies we have. We give away many sleeping bags. We talk. We listen. We worship together. We try to connect people with resources and services – at least for those who want them. They aren’t they or them at all. They are us and we are them.
We don’t make people earn dinner. We don’t make them earn clean clothes. We don’t make them earn showers. We believe that people should be treated with dignity and value. We believe that people have names and stories and lives. We believe that people should be empowered to make decisions for their lives. We believe we can’t fix people – we’re broken too, just in different ways. We believe we are called to be with these people and see the image of God in each person we encounter. And we blessed by them too.
And the crazy thing about all of this is that this works. In several instances, we’ve been able to help people get off the streets and out of living in their vehicles and start living in apartments and houses. We don’t have a ton of resources. But we have something else – we have faith. And we share that faith with people. We have a ministry of presence – being present with those who need someone to recognize that they exist and are human beings.
Regardless of what happens at the federal level, we’ll keep doing our ministry of presence. We’ll keep living out our faith. And I’m willing to bet, we’ll keep seeing results – that people’s lives are transformed, that people are becoming part of a community that cares for one another, that people are relearning to trust others, that people actually care whether someone is alive or dead, that people deserve dignity, that everyone has a story, and that all are welcome at God’s table – even when that table is a truck stop diner where communion is shared.
Thanx for this vital information. You help me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for reading it.
LikeLike
Pingback: Different approaches to homelessness — Laced up Lutheran | Talmidimblogging
Better to give a little with love than to try and force someone’s will into doing something. When we were homeless we were thankful for even the smallest of kindnesses freely given. What we did not appreciate was people using organizations and system to beat people into their definition of being a ‘productive’ citizen. Might as well bring back the debtor’s prisons from Dicken’s time for all the good it will do. We hated that kind of forceful coercion just to get a meal or shelter and ran from it wherever we found it. We freely chose to sleep outside in the winter, in snowbanks, than to accept anything other than the lead of God. After one horrible experience our family of 4 (two daughters) absolutely refused to stay in a shelter ever again.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Thanks for sharing this Homer. I’m sorry that you experienced this. Too often those that come from a “healthier” financial situation forget that God doesn’t require anything form them in order to receive grace. We are called to offer grace in the same way.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Thanx for this insight. Well said. Helpful.
God bless…
LikeLiked by 3 people
Without much research, I do tend to like your approach of serving without strings attached. I can imagine some churches/resources requiring attendance in service or something of that nature. Giving generously without strings seems to be the Biblical approach.
LikeLiked by 3 people
HOSPITALITY.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Pingback: Why I believe what I believe about homelessness | Laced up Lutheran